Recent Posts81
Renewable Energy Q&A / Re: Max winding temp
« Last post by lighthunter on April 19, 2022, 12:19:28 am »Hi Pete, I really appreciate the input, great info there.
"I would start by checking the motor current rating against what it is actually drawing under load"
This was my first clue something wasnt right, the nameplate current was FLA 166 460V 60hz, 110kw, SFA190, 94.5effic,, 680KG, Frame TEFC, SF1.15, PF .88.
Rpm 3585
What i saw was the amperage at 400v climbed to 160A at full load. The catch though is i remember the guy saying that he used smaller wire for some reason on the rebuild. So who knows what it can handle. Nameplate data is questionable. Upon install i squeezed a temp sensor under some windings i could reach through the box. I ran it for 40 hours initially at full load and it survived but had 0°C cooling air of a couple thousand CFM. Im sure it would not survive now.
Admittedly im being cautious but its obvious its days would be numbered if i just increased temp setting to 250F and pushed the start button and walked away. I dont need 100% capacity so id be ok with 70% but i need to get the voltage up somehow or it cant even do that. I could boost the 80V with 3 toroids with 200A 80V secondaries. Ive in fact had to do this in the past to level shift voltage and it worked well still in use to my knowledge. but doing this would cause current on the ground wire (common for the Y feeder) and i think the distribution has GFCI so that would cause a fault. I may have to get the software from the vfd mfr and somehow configure the pressure control loop another way. I just hate to alter an oem machine but when they violate such basic things as rated voltage on a motor... The motor failure under warranty proves it was a bad idea. Its possible they will still come through with the codes to change it but im not counting on it.
I just had a crazy thought, maybe nameplate volts is for wye and mfr. Is using as delta, that would explain?? Nope, just looked, nameplate says 460 with triangle which means delta which is how we are connected.
No blue color on windings. I will try to find out.
What do you think the temperature difference between core and surface of windings is? Thermal transfer of copper is good but the varnish has to slow that down some.
How can i go about calculating heat generated in the motor? For example if i know volts, amps, rpm and frequency, i can calculate slippage at a known input power. This might give me an idea of the red zone of loading. Im guessing all motors exhibit a normal range of slip and anything beyond a certain point results in an overheat motor.
Looks like ive only got two options, reduce load, or increase voltage. I guess replacing motor or scrapping compressor might be options as well but would not make those happy who've just spent $14k on it.
On my inverter, I think the toroid is ok with the temp, it just as pretty as the day i finished winding it. There is a monster 243 cfm fan that I will set to run more often though. Maybe having the fuses in the hot air stream is a good backstop for temp limits due to an improper fan setting
" SMA 2kw GTI inverter. I am thinking of connecting it up as a mini grid but obviously need to have a voltage sensitive relay on the batteries to prevent overcharging."
Hook it up, you wont ever regret that. They are so efficient you would be amazed. I had a group of 12 panels direct connected through relays, 29 volt panels two in series, 6 sets in parallel. Never got even close to 2kw. Connected in series, on a grid tie, I saw those same panels run near 3kw whenever sun is shining. I think they are 240W panels. I will admit my wiring was not perfect but it was night and day difference in power. You can control output in a number of ways. I use high volt relays just on/off with 30 min time delay but a common relay can be used with a dump resistor to parallel across the dc inputs and cut output in half. Or a relay on AC side with a 1 to 2 kw water heater element. You can never have too much power:)
"I would start by checking the motor current rating against what it is actually drawing under load"
This was my first clue something wasnt right, the nameplate current was FLA 166 460V 60hz, 110kw, SFA190, 94.5effic,, 680KG, Frame TEFC, SF1.15, PF .88.
Rpm 3585
What i saw was the amperage at 400v climbed to 160A at full load. The catch though is i remember the guy saying that he used smaller wire for some reason on the rebuild. So who knows what it can handle. Nameplate data is questionable. Upon install i squeezed a temp sensor under some windings i could reach through the box. I ran it for 40 hours initially at full load and it survived but had 0°C cooling air of a couple thousand CFM. Im sure it would not survive now.
Admittedly im being cautious but its obvious its days would be numbered if i just increased temp setting to 250F and pushed the start button and walked away. I dont need 100% capacity so id be ok with 70% but i need to get the voltage up somehow or it cant even do that. I could boost the 80V with 3 toroids with 200A 80V secondaries. Ive in fact had to do this in the past to level shift voltage and it worked well still in use to my knowledge. but doing this would cause current on the ground wire (common for the Y feeder) and i think the distribution has GFCI so that would cause a fault. I may have to get the software from the vfd mfr and somehow configure the pressure control loop another way. I just hate to alter an oem machine but when they violate such basic things as rated voltage on a motor... The motor failure under warranty proves it was a bad idea. Its possible they will still come through with the codes to change it but im not counting on it.
I just had a crazy thought, maybe nameplate volts is for wye and mfr. Is using as delta, that would explain?? Nope, just looked, nameplate says 460 with triangle which means delta which is how we are connected.
No blue color on windings. I will try to find out.
What do you think the temperature difference between core and surface of windings is? Thermal transfer of copper is good but the varnish has to slow that down some.
How can i go about calculating heat generated in the motor? For example if i know volts, amps, rpm and frequency, i can calculate slippage at a known input power. This might give me an idea of the red zone of loading. Im guessing all motors exhibit a normal range of slip and anything beyond a certain point results in an overheat motor.
Looks like ive only got two options, reduce load, or increase voltage. I guess replacing motor or scrapping compressor might be options as well but would not make those happy who've just spent $14k on it.
On my inverter, I think the toroid is ok with the temp, it just as pretty as the day i finished winding it. There is a monster 243 cfm fan that I will set to run more often though. Maybe having the fuses in the hot air stream is a good backstop for temp limits due to an improper fan setting
" SMA 2kw GTI inverter. I am thinking of connecting it up as a mini grid but obviously need to have a voltage sensitive relay on the batteries to prevent overcharging."
Hook it up, you wont ever regret that. They are so efficient you would be amazed. I had a group of 12 panels direct connected through relays, 29 volt panels two in series, 6 sets in parallel. Never got even close to 2kw. Connected in series, on a grid tie, I saw those same panels run near 3kw whenever sun is shining. I think they are 240W panels. I will admit my wiring was not perfect but it was night and day difference in power. You can control output in a number of ways. I use high volt relays just on/off with 30 min time delay but a common relay can be used with a dump resistor to parallel across the dc inputs and cut output in half. Or a relay on AC side with a 1 to 2 kw water heater element. You can never have too much power:)
. Ok rant end.